MEPVirtual - Engineering Knowledge Hub MEPVirtual
MV-507 · Phase 2 Design & analysis

MV Protection & Relay Coordination

Set the upstream feeder relay, the transformer feeder protection in the RMU and the LV main ACB. The TCC chart redraws live, the checks tell you where discrimination fails, and a fault simulation shows the trip order.

In short

  • IEC IDMT curves follow t = TMS × k / ((I/Is)α − 1). Standard inverse uses k = 0.14 and α = 0.02.
  • A grading margin of about 0.3 to 0.4 s between relays is common. It covers breaker opening time, relay overshoot and errors.
  • Transformer protection must ride through inrush (often about 12 × In for 0.1 s) and still clear before the transformer's thermal withstand limit.
  • An HV fuse is often faster than the LV main ACB for faults on the LV board, so full discrimination usually needs a circuit breaker and relay on the transformer feeder.
  • All curves are plotted on one voltage base. LV currents are divided by the transformer ratio to compare them with MV devices.

TCC Coordination Plotter 2D Animated

Adjust each device. Curves are plotted in amps at the MV voltage. Pick a fault and press play to watch each device's timer run and see which one trips first.

1. Upstream feeder relay (primary substation)

2. RMU transformer feeder

3. LV main ACB (LSI)

Coordination checks

    CT Knee-Point Sizing Calc

    Check that a protection CT will not saturate before the relay operates. The required knee-point voltage depends on the maximum fault current, the CT and lead resistance and the relay burden.

    How do IDMT relays work?

    An inverse definite minimum time (IDMT) relay trips faster as the current rises. The pickup setting Is sets where it starts timing, the time multiplier (TMS) moves the whole curve up or down, and the curve type sets its shape. Standard inverse suits networks where fault current changes little with location. Very and extremely inverse curves grade better with fuses and with downstream devices where fault current falls steeply along the circuit.

    IEC curvekα
    Standard inverse (SI)0.140.02
    Very inverse (VI)13.51
    Extremely inverse (EI)802
    Long time inverse (LTI)1201

    What is a grading margin?

    For a fault downstream, the device closest to the fault must trip first, and the next device upstream must wait long enough not to trip as well. The margin covers the downstream breaker's opening time, relay overshoot, CT errors and a safety allowance. 0.3 to 0.4 s is typical between electromechanical-style settings, and numerical relays with fast breakers may use about 0.25 s.

    Why use a CB instead of fuses on larger transformers?

    For a fault on the LV main board, the HV fuse often melts before the LV ACB's short-time delay ends, so the whole transformer is lost instead of only the LV breaker tripping. A CB with a relay can be set with a time delay that grades with the ACB, and it also allows earth fault, temperature and gas relay trips. This is one reason utilities move from F units to V units above roughly 1000 to 1250 kVA.

    ExpertDelta-star transformers change how phase-to-phase and earth faults appear on the HV side. An LV phase-to-phase fault shows up as 1.15 times the equivalent three-phase current in one HV phase, and LV earth faults are not seen at all by HV earth fault relays. Use restricted earth fault (REF) on the LV winding for sensitive transformer earth fault protection.

    Regional notes

    GCC

    Utilities set the primary feeder relays and publish the settings envelope that consumer substations must grade with. Transformer feeder protection in utility RMUs is often fixed by the utility standard.

    Australia and New Zealand

    Network operators specify protection for HV customers and require a protection study for HV installations. Selectivity on the LV side follows AS/NZS 3000.

    Asia

    Utilities such as TNB and SP Group publish protection settings requirements for consumer substations and expect a coordination study with the submission.

    Test yourself

    0 / 8

    8 questions. Pick an answer to see the explanation. Practise about 50 more MV-507 questions in the MV Question Bank.

    Frequently asked questions

    What is a typical grading margin between relays?
    About 0.3 to 0.4 s for traditional practice, and around 0.25 s with numerical relays and fast vacuum breakers. The margin covers breaker opening time, overshoot, CT errors and a safety margin.
    What is the IEC standard inverse formula?
    t = TMS x 0.14 / ((I/Is)^0.02 - 1). Very inverse uses 13.5 and 1, extremely inverse 80 and 2, and long time inverse 120 and 1.
    How do I stop transformer inrush tripping the relay?
    Make sure the relay or fuse curve is above the inrush point, often taken as about 12 times rated current for 0.1 s, or use harmonic restraint on numerical relays.
    How do I size a CT knee-point voltage?
    A common check is Vk ≥ K x If x (Rct + 2RL + Rrelay), with If the maximum secondary fault current, RL the one-way lead resistance and K a transient factor from the relay manufacturer.

    Standards referenced

    • IEC 60255-151 Overcurrent relays
    • IEC 60282-1 HV fuses
    • IEC 60947-2 LV circuit-breakers
    • IEC 61869-2 Current transformers
    • IEC 60076-5 Transformer short-circuit withstand
    NEXT STEP

    Where to go from here

    Related labs that pick up where this one ends.

    Medium Voltage hubAll 16 MV labs and the 788-question MV bank.MV HUBShort Circuit & Load Flow StudioIEC 60909 short circuit from the 11 kV source to the final DB: three-phase and earth fault levels, peak…MV-506 · previousMV Earthing & Step/Touch LabDesign a substation earth grid to IEEE 80: grid resistance, GPR, mesh and step voltage against tolerable…MV-508 · nextProtection & Coordination StudioGrade HV relays, fuses and LV breakers on a live time-current chart, simulate faults in 4D, test 87T…HV-507 · HV view
    Track what you have opened on My progress.All labs → · Ask the Copilot →

    © 2026 Eng. Mannan Maqsood | Engineering Excellence Through Interactive Labs

    VERIFY ALL FIGURES AGAINST CURRENT MANUFACTURER DATASHEETS AND LOCAL AUTHORITY REQUIREMENTS BEFORE DESIGN SIGN-OFF.

    Share this pageFollow